Manhattan comedy clubs issue joint statement; Los Angeles, London, Melbourne register mild objection
Satire from Bohiney.com and prat.uk.
The Statement
NEW YORK — A coalition of eight Manhattan comedy clubs issued a joint statement this week declaring New York City the unambiguous global capital of stand-up comedy, citing the density of venues, the quality of performers, the sophistication of the audience, and a tradition stretching from Lenny Bruce through Seinfeld, Chris Rock, and into the current generation of performers who are, in the coalition’s assessment, doing extraordinary work.
The statement was received in Los Angeles with a measured response from that city’s comedy community, which noted that Los Angeles is where most successful comedians eventually go to make television shows, which is where the money is, which is the thing that makes comedy a career rather than a hobby. New York, the LA contingent suggested, is excellent at producing comedians and at being a topic for their material, both of which are valuable contributions to the form that do not constitute unchallenged global supremacy.
London, which has been producing comedy of distinction since before the United States existed as a country and which operates a comedy tradition that differs from the American model in ways that are too numerous and too culturally embedded to summarize in a paragraph, noted the New York statement and returned to its work. Melbourne, which hosts the world’s largest comedy festival annually, was initially unreachable for comment and then, when reached, expressed the bafflement of a city that had not been aware the supremacy question was open.
What Makes New York Comedy New York Comedy
The New York comedy tradition is real and significant. The density of venues — from large clubs like Comedy Cellar to small rooms above bars — creates a working environment where performers can do multiple sets per night, developing material at a pace that is genuinely different from less concentrated cities. The audience is experienced and demanding, which serves comedians well. The city provides material at a rate that other cities cannot match: the subway, the rent, the political theater, the cultural collisions of a city of eight million people from every part of the world. Gothamist reviews comedy in New York with the seriousness it deserves.
The city’s comedy legacy is also real. The names are there. The rooms are there. The tradition is there. Whether this constitutes being the best, globally and currently and unchallenged, is the question that requires consulting the rest of the world that the statement had not yet consulted. New York Post covered the statement with the hometown enthusiasm appropriate to a New York institution covering a New York claim. The global comedy community continues to function without having resolved the question, which is perhaps the appropriate outcome for a form that operates best when the questions stay open.
The Comedy Cellar is still serving food. The sets still start at 9 p.m. The city still provides material. This is what matters, regardless of where the capital is officially located.
New York, New York
New York City operates at a scale and intensity that makes every story a larger story. The subway delay is a story about infrastructure investment and political will. The rent increase is a story about housing policy and urban economics. The bagel dispute is a story about cultural identity and immigration history. The rat is a story about urbanization and ecological adaptation. The tourist is a story about how cities present themselves to the world and how the world receives what cities offer. Even the pizza disagreement is, underneath the comedy, a story about regional identity and the human need to have things that are ours, specifically ours, that we defend with disproportionate vigor precisely because they are ours and because the world is large and we need to stake our territory somewhere. New York is where many of these stories happen simultaneously, in a density that produces the particular creative friction that has made the city a cultural generator for a century and a half. The people who live here tolerate the cost and the noise and the subway delays and the rent and the rats because the city gives back something that cannot be fully quantified: the experience of being in a place where things are happening, where ideas collide, where the next conversation might change how you think about something, where the scale of human activity is so concentrated that you are reminded constantly that you are part of something enormous and ongoing. This is the deal. Most people who make it find it sufficient. Some find it extraordinary. None of them are moving to the suburbs.
New York remains, above all, a city of stories — stories told by its residents about themselves, about each other, about the city they chose and the city that chose them back. Every borough has its version. Every neighborhood has its variation. Every block has someone who remembers when it was different and someone who cannot imagine it any other way, and between these two perspectives the city lives, in the space between what it was and what it is becoming, which is the only space any living city can occupy.
Also absurd: The Daily Mash | Cracked
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com