Midtown encounter produces comprehensive unsolicited oral dissertation on correct method of holding New York opinions, tourist misses museum
Bohiney Magazine | The London Prat
MIDTOWN MANHATTAN, NEW YORK — A New York City resident spent forty-three minutes on the corner of 49th Street and Seventh Avenue on Wednesday explaining to a tourist from Columbus, Ohio, why the tourist’s expressed opinion that New York City was “pretty cool but maybe a little overwhelming” was incorrect, reflecting a fundamental misunderstanding of the city’s operational logic, an inappropriate use of the modifier “pretty,” and a failure to appreciate that “overwhelming” is not a critique but a descriptor of the city’s core feature, which the tourist would understand if he had been here longer, which he had not, and which the New Yorker was therefore addressing, comprehensively, right now, on this corner.
The Encounter
The tourist, identified as Derek Hollingsworth, 44, a regional sales manager from Columbus visiting New York for the first time with his wife and two teenage children, made the initial comment while consulting a paper map outside the Rockefeller Center complex and had not directed it at anyone in particular. The New Yorker, who gave his name as Phil and declined to provide a surname because he said he did not owe that information to anyone, said he had “happened to hear it” and felt “a kind of civic responsibility to engage.”
Phil, 38, a graphic designer who has lived in New York for eleven years, spent the first ten minutes of the encounter establishing that “pretty cool” was not an adequate characterization of New York City, which he said was “the most significant human settlement in the Western Hemisphere” and which deserved a response “commensurate with its stature.” He spent the following twelve minutes explaining what “overwhelming” actually meant in a New York context, which he said was “the city operating at its designed specifications” rather than a flaw. He spent the remaining twenty-one minutes on what he called “the full picture,” which covered transit, food, culture, architecture, the outer boroughs as a concept, the historical significance of the grid plan, and why Columbus was, in his view, “fine.”
The Tourist’s Experience
Hollingsworth said he had originally been attempting to find the entrance to the Top of the Rock observation deck, for which his family had tickets valid at 2:00 p.m., which was forty-three minutes ago. He said Phil had been “very informative” and that he now had “a much more detailed sense of how New Yorkers feel about New York” and that he had not been able to get a word in for approximately thirty-six of the forty-three minutes.
He said Phil had at no point asked where he was from, what had brought him to New York, how long he was staying, or what he thought of the city beyond the initial comment that had triggered the conversation, which Hollingsworth noted was “not actually a complaint” but “more of a general impression” that he would now qualify differently if given the opportunity.
“I think I would say something like ‘extraordinary’ next time,” Hollingsworth said. “Or maybe just not say anything near anyone who might be a New Yorker. I should have been more careful.”
His wife Sandra said she had attempted to end the conversation three times using what she described as “increasingly clear body language” and had eventually resorted to physically taking her husband’s arm and walking toward the Rockefeller Center entrance, at which point Phil had called after them that they should also try the Frick Collection if they had time, which he said was “underrated, unlike this city, which is correctly rated.”
Phil’s Perspective
Phil, reached by phone, said he felt the conversation had been “genuinely helpful” to the tourist and that he had “no regrets.” He said he was aware that he had caused the family to miss their observation deck reservation but noted that the view of New York from the ground, which is free, was “arguably more authentic than the view from a paid tourist platform.”
He said he did this kind of thing “fairly regularly” when he heard New York characterized in terms he found “imprecise” and that he considered it part of being “an engaged citizen of a city that people often think they understand after forty-eight hours when it actually takes years.”
Asked whether he had ever considered that tourists might prefer to form their own opinions, Phil said he had considered it and believed it reflected “a passive approach to civic engagement” that he was “not personally comfortable with.” He said his girlfriend had raised similar points. He said they were working through it. The Hollingsworth family, for their part, rebooked the observation deck for Thursday and said they were otherwise having a wonderful trip. They have not encountered Phil again. They are watching carefully.
Phil, the New Yorker who conducted the forty-three-minute explanation, was contacted a second time for this article and said he had a “fairly extensive” backlog of similar conversations he had initiated with tourists over the years, and that he kept informal notes on the exchanges, and that he was considering a book. He said the book would be about “the gap between how people experience New York on a short visit and what New York actually is, and why that gap matters, and what closing it would require.” He said he expected the book to be around 400 pages. He said he had an outline. He said the outline was currently 180 pages. This publication did not ask a follow-up question. The Hollingsworth family completed their New York trip on Friday. They went to the Frick Collection, at Phil’s recommendation. They said it was, genuinely, underrated. They would not say this to Phil directly. They are from Columbus. They know better now.
Offering unsolicited opinions at The London Prat and Bohiney Magazine.
Also not asked at The Onion | Cracked | The Daily Mash
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/new-yorker-explains-tourist-opinion-wrong-43-minutes-manhattan/
