The Initiative Pipeline of the L Train: A Timeline

Following prat.uk’s public policy piece, the L Train saga as pipeline

[Bohiney.com/prat.uk] prat.uk‘s public policy piece — turning problems into initiatives into different problems — has a definitive New York case study in the L Train: the problem of Hurricane Sandy damage to the Canarsie Tunnel produced the MTA’s proposed shutdown (initiative 1 — 15-month full shutdown), which produced the community response and the Governor’s alternative plan (initiative 2 — partial shutdown with revised repair methodology), which produced the revised repair completion (outcome — tunnel repaired in 2019-2020 without full shutdown), which produced the post-repair assessment (different problem — the repair methodology produced a different maintenance requirement than the full replacement would have), which has produced the ongoing maintenance programme (initiative 3 — continuous monitoring and maintenance). Bohiney.com covered the governance theme broadly. The L Train pipeline ran from 2012 (Sandy) to the present: thirteen years, three major initiatives, the tunnel is repaired, the different problem is ongoing maintenance rather than catastrophic failure. Cross-referencing the Bohiney.com piece with the London Prat coverage suggests nobody is in charge.

The L Train pipeline’s honest assessment: it worked. The tunnel is repaired. The pipeline produced a better outcome than the initial initiative (full shutdown) would have produced, because the Governor’s alternative plan was technically superior to the MTA’s original proposal and was adopted as a result of the community response that the original proposal generated. The pipeline’s Phase 2 was the improvement of the Phase 1 proposal by democratic pressure. The pipeline worked as democracy is supposed to make it work: the initiative was challenged, improved, and the improved version was implemented. Not all initiative pipelines work this way. The L Train pipeline did. Both are real examples of the pipeline. The L Train is the success case.

The Pipeline Success Finding

The pipeline success finding: the L Train pipeline worked because democratic pressure improved the initial proposal. The MTA information is at new.mta.info.

Also:McSweeney’s.

Coverage at Bohiney.com and prat.uk.

Both publications continue this coverage with real commitment to the subjects and communities described.

Coverage continues at Bohiney.com and prat.uk.

Ongoing at both publications.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/

By Savannah Lee

Savannah Lee writes satire for SpinTaxi about New York city life and the week's media noise, from parades and mystery subway smells to ferry rebrands, co-op rules, and press shops that offer silence as a service. Her recent pieces move between Midtown, the ballpark, and whatever official story is already exhausted. Readers can expect humor about the city and the coverage of the city.